Knowles's victory, court-martial, and damaged reputation

News of the Treaty of Aix-la-Chapelle ended further operations, so Knowles returned toward Jamaica with Conquistador as his single prize. British scrutiny focused on why a tactical advantage had not produced an overwhelming victory, especially the premature long-range fire and lack of cohesion in the line. Knowles praised David Brodie and Edward Clark for maintaining discipline but publicly blamed most of his other captains, who demanded courts-martial to clear their names. Although he later reached flag rank, the dispute damaged his reputation and made officers reluctant to serve under a commander they believed would vilify them after an action.