Q&A · 3:55:59-3:56:26

Why Kimmel took the Pacific Fleet command

The command transition is tied to unequal access to strategic information and the political cost of challenging presidential fleet policy.

Question

Why did Husband Kimmel take command of the Pacific Fleet after James Richardson's opposition to its basing did not change policy?

Short answer

Richardson used the information available to him to challenge Roosevelt, whereas Kimmel did not receive the same information and therefore could not argue from the same position.

Notes

Richardson's resistance helped lead to Kimmel taking command, but the two officers did not have the same information. Richardson could use what he knew to argue directly against Roosevelt's policy, while Kimmel was not given the same basis for opposition.