Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 1:44:10-1:44:31

Kaga and Ark Royal answered different naval plans

A comparison between Kaga and HMS Ark Royal has to account for the different fleet roles their navies intended them to perform.

Aircraft CarriersJapanese NavyRoyal NavyWarship Design
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

Can the Japanese carrier Kaga be compared directly with HMS Ark Royal?

Short answer

Only with care, because each carrier was designed for a different navy's plans and could be effective within its own intended role.

Notes

The Japanese carrier Kaga and HMS Ark Royal can be compared with care. Each navy built its ship around different plans and intended roles. A feature that looks superior in isolation may matter less than whether the carrier fits its wider fleet system. The comparison applies a central design-history lesson: judge a warship against what its navy expected it to accomplish.