Q&A · 6:28:37-6:29:09

Which navy most needed a Black Swan-type escort?

Japan's shortage of escorts supplies the context for choosing it as the navy that would benefit most from a Black Swan-like class.

Question

Which navy would benefit most from a class like the Royal Navy's Black Swans?

Short answer

The Japanese navy, in the context of its shortage of escorts.

Notes

Japan is the immediate choice when asked which navy would benefit most from a class like the Royal Navy's Black Swans. The question follows a debate over the threat Japanese escorts posed to submarines attempting surface gun attacks. Too few escorts having been built is the explanation offered in reply to a claim that escort work was considered dishonorable. The recommendation remains brief, without specifications for an alternative Japanese escort design.