Q&A · 1:43:59

Italian unification and merchant shipping

British support for Italian unification is not explained by a wish to eliminate Neapolitan merchant competition, because unification combined rather than erased the peninsula's maritime capacity.

Question

Did Britain support Italian unification in order to eliminate the merchant navy of Naples as a competitor?

Short answer

No. Unification enlarged and combined Italian maritime capacity rather than removing the merchant fleet of Naples.

Notes

A viewer proposes that Britain supported Italian unification in order to remove the merchant navy of Naples as a competitor. The explanation fails because creating a larger Italian state would not make Neapolitan shipping disappear. Unification instead combined that capacity with the maritime resources associated with places such as Venice and Genoa. An account of foreign policy should be tested against the material consequence of the policy it claims to explain.