Q&A · 1:35:39-1:38:01

An improved Warrior as a doctrine of overmatch

Four larger, two-deck Warriors are proposed as a precedent for more ambitious British capital-ship designs.

Question

Which Royal Navy construction decision from the past would be worth changing?

Short answer

Build four larger, two-deck Warriors to establish overwhelming superiority as the standard for later Royal Navy designs.

Notes

The proposed intervention is to choose the larger two-deck version of Warrior and order four ships rather than two. Its immediate purpose would be overwhelming superiority over Gloire. That success is imagined as a precedent for more ambitious Dreadnought and Queen Elizabeth designs. Warrior's seagoing speed would also make a poor match for Monitor's specialized inshore role, with Monitor expected to struggle even to reach an open-ocean engagement. A separate counterfactual judgment is that Virginia might have cracked Monitor's armour if supplied with solid shot.