Notable Point · 41:18-42:37

The disputed weapon that sank HMS Janus

Fritz X, Hs 293 and a conventional torpedo appear in competing accounts of Janus's loss.

Notes

The weapon that sank Janus remains disputed in this account, with Fritz X, Hs 293 and a conventional torpedo all considered. A very heavy warhead is judged the most plausible explanation for the damage. The torpedo theory is treated as unlikely because there was no apparent torpedo-bomber run, nearby submarine attack or exchange of torpedoes between ships. Even a well-built destroyer could break apart if enough explosive struck the wrong place. Janus sank in about twenty minutes, and only eighty crew members survived, most rescued by HMS Laforey.