Q&A · 1:38:47-1:41:05

Why is HMS Hind's commander uncertain?

Conflicting accounts assign HMS Hind to different officers, leaving its commander unverified here.

Command Records Historical Uncertainty HMS Hind Naval Historiography Orders Of Battle Royal Navy Source Criticism

Watch at this time Full video guide

Question

Who commanded HMS Hind at the Battle of Navarino?

Short answer

The surviving accounts conflict, leaving the command attribution unresolved here.

Notes

A viewer asks who commanded the cutter HMS Hind at Navarino. Different histories assign the vessel to different officers. Neither account supplied enough confirmation to resolve the discrepancy during the lecture. Leaving the name open is therefore a source-critical choice, not an omission to be filled by guessing.