Q&A ยท 3:33:09-3:33:42

Why HMS Devastation was not quite a monitor

Devastation's low freeboard makes the comparison understandable, but her intended battleship role places her just outside the monitor category.

Question

Could HMS Devastation be considered a monitor because of her low freeboard?

Short answer

Not under the strict definition; her form approaches a monitor, but her design and intended battleship role keep her outside the category.

Notes

HMS Devastation shares the low silhouette and low freeboard associated with monitors. Classification, however, depends on intended service as well as appearance. She was designed and employed as a battleship rather than as the more restricted type implied by a strict monitor definition. The result is a close visual analogy without a true doctrinal match.