Q&A ยท 3:12:18-3:13:13

Testing claims about the first naval smoke screen

A claim for the first naval smoke screen in 1917 fails because German ships used smoke at Jutland and earlier examples also exist.

Question

Could Captain Horvey's 1917 smoke screen really have been the first in history?

Short answer

No; German smoke at Jutland and still earlier uses make the claim untenable.

Notes

German smoke at Jutland and earlier examples make the claimed 1917 first untenable. Modern publicity claims that label new ships the first drone carriers repeat the same mistake. HMS Agamemnon's operation of Queen Bee target drones in 1939 supplies a parallel warning: striking labels often ignore earlier cases that already satisfy the definition. The moment is a compact lesson in checking historical superlatives against precedent.