Q&A · 56:58-58:59

Could Hiryū have escaped Midway?

Hiryū could have withdrawn, but only by abandoning the counterstrike that crippled Yorktown.

Question

Could Hiryū have escaped or withdrawn from the Battle of Midway?

Short answer

Yes, if her commander withdrew rather than launching the strike on Yorktown; the counterattack and escape were incompatible choices.

Notes

Hiryū could have withdrawn if her commander had chosen escape instead of another attack. That choice would have cancelled the strike against Yorktown. Preserving the Japanese carrier therefore meant giving up an opportunity to damage the American carrier force.