Q&A · 2:34:56-2:40:35

Grant compared with Moltke as a strategist

Grant's repeated operations and political difficulties give him a slight edge over Moltke in this comparative judgment.

Question

Was Moltke rather than Grant the general who best understood strategy and movement in the 1860s?

Short answer

Moltke was outstanding, but Grant receives a slight edge because he had to apply comparable ideas more often, on a larger scale, and amid greater political complication.

Notes

Moltke receives credit for his strategic ideas and skill in manoeuvre. Grant has a slight edge in this comparison because he had to conduct such operations repeatedly and on a larger scale. The later qualification places particular weight on the political complications Grant faced.