Q&A · 2:19:19-2:20:59

Graf Zeppelin and the danger of an undefined end state

Germany's unfinished carrier becomes a case study in why a defense project needs a clear, testable end state.

Question

Which naval project most deserves the reaction, 'What were they thinking?' despite having time and resources?

Short answer

Graf Zeppelin is his leading example because the Germans tried to embody many untested carrier ideas at once instead of defining and delivering a working aircraft carrier.

Notes

A project is in danger when its desired end state cannot be stated in one clear sentence. Graf Zeppelin accumulated experimental carrier concepts as though the ship were a universal test bed, while the practical requirement should have been narrower: produce an aircraft carrier that could reliably operate.