Q&A · 2:21:16-2:22:50

The design choice German destroyers could not avoid

German destroyer design suffered from trying to combine a cruiser-scale gun with destroyer duties.

Question

Could Germany have improved its destroyers by acquiring British J-, K-, and L-class plans?

Short answer

There were many ways to improve them, but the central issue was deciding whether they were destroyers or small cruisers rather than mixing the two concepts.

Notes

A 5.9-inch weapon is a good gun but belongs on a hull stable enough to use it properly. A destroyer fighting at high speed and closer range instead benefits from lighter guns, higher volume of fire, and twin mounts. The real design decision is whether to build a destroyer or a small cruiser, rather than an unhappy hybrid.