Q&A · 23:13-25:13

Why coastal-defence ships deter only some opponents

A German coastal-battleship alternative shows why local armoured ships can deter lesser powers without stopping a navy that already possesses a full battle fleet.

Question

Would heavily armed coastal battleships have been worthwhile for Germany's home defence?

Short answer

They could deter smaller powers, but not the Royal Navy; building enough to resist a major battle fleet would erase their cost advantage.

Notes

Coastal-defence ships raise the force and risk required for an attack, which makes them useful to states such as Norway or Sweden against smaller naval powers. Their deterrent value depends on requiring an attacker to bring a battle fleet. A power that already possesses such a fleet can concentrate enough strength to overwhelm them, so they offer Germany little protection against the Royal Navy. Building a large fleet of coastal battleships would also defeat their economic purpose, which is to avoid the expense of a full battle fleet and release money for other needs.