Q&A ยท 50:51-51:16

A frigate-heavy 1806 fleet still needs third rates

Quality frigates and razees create useful cruising strength, but ships of the line remain necessary to give the fleet battle strength.

Question

Is a quality advantage in razees and 24-pounder frigates the right approach for building an 1806 fleet?

Short answer

It provides strength, but the fleet should also keep adding third rates whenever possible.

Notes

The proposed alternative fleet emphasizes a small number of razees and a larger force of 24-pounder frigates. That combination would create useful cruising strength. Third-rate ships of the line would still be needed whenever resources permitted. The frigate plan therefore belongs inside a balanced fleet rather than replacing line-of-battle ships.