Q&A · 2:13:05-2:14:29

Could fleet prestige encourage a West Indies federation?

The federation proposal uses Canada's imagined position at an imperial conference to explain the prestige attached to naval contributions.

Question

Could the creation of colonial fleets provide the push needed for a West Indies federation?

Short answer

It could help if colonies saw a shared fleet as a way to avoid losing status beside better-equipped imperial partners.

Notes

Shared naval ambitions could give Caribbean colonies a reason to federate. The proposed motive is anxiety about being treated as a lesser participant while other imperial governments supplied fleets. Canada illustrates the same pressure in the hypothetical 1910 imperial conference: arriving without ships while Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, and India had capital ships would weaken its standing. Politicians are expected to resist that loss of status, giving a shared fleet an additional political appeal.