Q&A · 3:06:49-3:07:19

Would 'frigate' have clarified Fisher's battlecruisers?

A strong preference for replacing Fisher's battlecruiser label with frigate meets an objection that frigate is itself excessively broad.

Question

Would Dr. Clarke force Jackie Fisher to call the type frigates instead of battlecruisers?

Short answer

Yes; the preference is firmly for frigate, although another participant finds that term too broadly used.

Notes

The preference is emphatically for frigate over battlecruiser in the hypothetical intervention with Fisher. Another participant objects that frigate itself is used for too many different things. The exchange establishes a naming preference and disagreement over the alternative term's breadth.