Q&A ยท 1:01:22-1:01:56

Could the First Sea Lord control every admiral's employment?

The First Sea Lord influenced appointments but could not personally dictate the shore careers of every senior officer.

Question

Did First Sea Lord Dudley Pound bear responsibility for leaving senior admirals unemployed?

Short answer

Not entirely; Pound tried to manage appointments, but senior officers ashore were difficult for any First Sea Lord to control personally.

Notes

First Sea Lord Dudley Pound did his best to manage appointments but did not possess complete personal control over every senior officer. An older naval saying captures the problem: admirals could be ordered at sea, while managing them ashore demanded more coercive power than one chief possessed. Flag-officer employment emerged from an institution and its personalities rather than from a single commander's plan. Pound therefore cannot carry sole responsibility for every underused admiral.