If an Egret-class sloop surprised an enemy destroyer, did it have enough gun power to defeat it?
Short answerPotentially: eight 4-inch guns could devastate an unarmoured destroyer, though the result would depend on the opponent and circumstances.
NotesThe outcome depends on the destroyer involved and on the Egret gaining surprise. Eight 4-inch guns could wreck an unarmoured destroyer's superstructure and damage its hull. Destroyers generally lacked armour that would let them shrug off repeated hits of that size. A sloop's nominal role does not prevent it from being dangerous in a favourable surface action.