Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 1:58:22-2:00:17

Could skipping Doolittle have strengthened Coral Sea?

Enterprise and Hornet could have reinforced Coral Sea, but removing Doolittle also removes the strategic shock imposed on Japan.

Battle of the Coral SeaDoolittle RaidStrategic EffectsUSS Enterprise (CV-6)USS Hornet (CV-8)
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

Without the Doolittle Raid, could the United States have overwhelmed Japan at Coral Sea?

Short answer

Possibly with Enterprise and Hornet added, but forgoing Doolittle would also remove its wider strategic and psychological effects.

Notes

Without the Doolittle Raid, Enterprise and Hornet might have joined Yorktown and Lexington at Coral Sea. Four American carriers could have produced a much stronger tactical position against the Japanese force. This counterfactual also removes the operation that demonstrated American reach against the home islands. A stronger Coral Sea force therefore comes at the cost of the psychological shock and defensive force allocation imposed on Japan by Doolittle.