Q&A · 58:31-1:00:11

Practical limits on a disguised merchant minelayer

A proposed liner-and-tug surprise attack could make a harbor mine-clearance nightmare, but local tug procedures and visible assistance would complicate the deception.

Question

Could a disabled-looking liner and tug secretly lay delayed mines while entering a harbor?

Short answer

It could create severe disruption, but local harbor tugs and normal port procedures would make the accompanying tug difficult to control or disguise.

Notes

An oceangoing tug might accompany a disabled ship, yet harbor authorities normally send local tugs with the knowledge and maneuverability needed inside port. A moon pool could conceal mine release from the merchant hull, but every extra vessel and unexplained movement adds opportunities for the deception to be detected.