Q&A · 25:47-26:02

Why Canada could support an old capital ship more readily than South Africa

Canada could plausibly build the supporting facilities for an old capital ship, while South Africa lacked the necessary dry-dock capacity.

Question

Could Britain have transferred an old battleship or battlecruiser to Canada or South Africa?

Short answer

Canada could probably build the required support infrastructure, but South Africa lacked the dry-docking facilities.

Notes

Handing over an old battlecruiser would transfer an infrastructure burden as well as a hull. Canada could build the facilities needed to support and maintain such a ship. South Africa was a poorer candidate because it lacked suitable dry-docking capacity. A navy cannot absorb a prestige vessel unless its bases can keep the ship operational.