Q&A ยท 1:11:32-1:12:05

Why a commando raid would not lure out the fleet

A covert raid could frighten or annoy the United States, but only a conspicuous fleet operation carried the scale needed to provoke a major naval response.

Question

Could Japan use a submarine-borne commando raid instead of sending carriers to the American coast?

Short answer

It could attempt one, but a covert raid lacked the political scale needed to provoke the full American fleet and imposed difficult infiltration requirements.

Notes

A viewer proposes commandos as a cheaper way to attack the American mainland. A small submarine-delivered raid would look covert and limited rather than like a challenge demanding the entire fleet. Infiltrators would also have to land undetected, cross a densely populated region around Los Angeles or San Francisco, carry enough explosives, and evade both military and police forces. The carrier fleet's visibility was therefore part of the strategic message: Japan needed the United States to see a major naval force and respond with its own fleet, not merely investigate sabotage.