Q&A · 2:53:13-2:53:52

Why combat damage claims should be discounted

Air, land, and naval forces all tend to overestimate the damage they inflict, even without deliberate deception.

Question

Why did commanders continue to believe optimistic claims about heavy-bomber accuracy and damage?

Short answer

Because combatants naturally overestimate what they have destroyed; planners should treat all service claims as uncertain rather than assume the reports are deliberate lies.

Notes

No service's destruction reports should be accepted at face value. Pilots, tank crews, and other combatants work with incomplete observations and can count the same or uncertain loss more than once. Sound operational analysis applies a consistent discount and looks for independent confirmation.