Q&A ยท 17:14-17:37

A preference for Collingwood over Nelson or Blake

Consider Collingwood's sustained Mediterranean command as a reason to prefer him in a comparison of leading admirals.

Question

Nelson or Blake, or would Collingwood be the better choice?

Short answer

The preference is for Collingwood, whose success kept him in Mediterranean command under successive governments.

Notes

Collingwood is the personal choice in this comparison. He served as second in command at Trafalgar and then took command in the Mediterranean, where governments of different political colours kept him because he performed so well. That prolonged service gave him fewer opportunities for the celebrated battle narrative associated with Nelson.