Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 4:04:45-4:05:43

Which close-in weapon system is best?

Kashtan's firepower, Phalanx's targeting, Bofors 40 mm guns, and uncertainty about a Chinese system complicate a single ranking of close-in weapons.

Bofors 40 mmClose-In Weapon SystemsKashtanNaval Air DefenceNaval GunneryPhalanx
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

Which close-in weapon system is best and which is worst?

Short answer

The systems have different strengths: Kashtan has substantial firepower, Phalanx strong targeting software, and Bofors 40 mm guns attract a favourable assessment. The Chinese system still needs demonstrated performance.

Notes

Kashtan has substantial firepower, although its targeting effectiveness remains uncertain. Its ship installation has more reliable power, processing capacity, and technical support than the Russian vehicle-mounted systems used as a comparison. Phalanx is preferred for its software and targeting, with reservations about the firepower of its 20 mm gun. Bofors 40 mm guns receive a favourable assessment. A Chinese system also appears promising, but confidence depends on seeing how effectively it works.