The appointment discussion describes naval officers putting forward candidates for consideration by the First Lord and prime minister. It argues that the composition of that list strongly influences the result. A short interim appointment is suggested as one way to bring in a senior figure during a crisis without making the usual longer commitment. An 18-month term, compared with the normal three years, could make an experienced officer willing to fill a vacancy caused by an unexpected death. Charles Forbes, then commanding the Home Fleet, is raised as another possible alternative to Pound. These alternatives are proposals made with hindsight, not appointments that took place.
Notable Point · 1:06:18-1:10:29
Choosing a First Sea Lord in a crisis
The shortlist for a senior appointment can shape the choice before ministers make the final decision.