Q&A ยท 46:37-47:31

Ching Lee in carrier command

A what-if question asks whether Vice Admiral Willis Lee would have changed the air side of the engagement if placed in a Spruance or Mitscher role.

Question

What would have happened if Vice Admiral Willis Lee had responsibility for the air side of the engagement?

Short answer

In Spruance's role Lee probably changes little; in Mitscher's role he might push earlier strikes, but his fit depends on whether he is acting as operational commander or carrier-force commander.

Notes

The answer depends on which job Lee receives. In Spruance's higher operational role, he probably changes little. In Mitscher's carrier-force role, Lee may have been aggressive enough to launch strikes early, though he was not primarily a carrier admiral. The exchange separates operational command, carrier tactical command, and battleship leadership in the U.S. structure.