Q&A ยท 5:14:47-5:15:50

Why coercive pincer maneuvers risk collisions

Close pincer maneuvers magnify collision risk when their target has skilled crews and machinery ready for a sudden burst of speed.

Question

What could make a collision during China's pincer maneuvers even more embarrassing?

Short answer

Involving a major asset would make the collision worse, while Philippine maneuvering skill and machinery readiness make slow pincer attempts difficult to execute.

Notes

A collision involving a major asset such as the Fujian carrier would be more damaging than one confined to smaller ships. Close pincer movements depend on the intercepting vessels having enough speed to constrain their target. Philippine Coast Guard crews are credited with skilled ship handling, supported by engineers and senior ratings who keep their machinery ready to accelerate when needed. Repeating the maneuver without sufficient speed risks another collision.