Q&A ยท 1:45:00-1:46:10

When a paper design is not a cancelled warship

The J class was built, while larger destroyer studies remained alternatives within the Admiralty.

Question

Was a 1937 J-class destroyer design cancelled?

Short answer

The J class was built. Larger alternatives considered within the Admiralty were unselected design options, so describing them as cancelled ships is misleading.

Notes

The built J class emerged from consideration of several destroyer options, including a larger design related to the Tribal approach. A drawing could progress through the naval constructors' office and Admiralty discussions without receiving an order. Describing every unselected option as a cancellation confuses design exploration with an abandoned construction programme.