Q&A · 50:46-51:13

Would Canadian battleships have led to carriers?

A counterfactual about Canadian capital ships turns on the Royal Navy's early belief that battleships needed carrier reconnaissance.

Question

If Canada had acquired battleships before the First World War, would it likely have acquired carriers before the Second?

Short answer

Probably: early-1920s Royal Navy thinking treated carrier reconnaissance as essential to an effective battleship squadron.

Notes

A Canadian battleship force before the First World War would probably have led to a carrier. By the early 1920s, the Royal Navy increasingly regarded a battleship squadron without carrier reconnaissance as a poor proposition. Carriers were becoming essential for finding the enemy and informing the battle fleet. In this counterfactual, Canada would inherit the reconnaissance problem that made a carrier part of a credible battleship force.