Q&A · 22:40-23:17

Why mechanical fire-control computers endured

The Difference Engine's mechanical fire-control premise is plausible because real mechanical fire-control tables remained effective for decades.

Question

What would limit a Babbage-style mechanical computer used for naval fire control?

Short answer

Mechanical fire-control tables remained useful into the 1960s and lasted longer for large guns, where replacing them required a new system that nobody had funded.

Notes

Mechanical fire-control tables remained useful into the 1960s. For large naval guns, they lasted longer because a replacement would require a new system designed from scratch. Funding that replacement was a separate obstacle from the ability to calculate a firing solution. This experience gives the Babbage-style naval computers in The Difference Engine a practical historical comparison.