Q&A · 1:49:31-1:51:23

Winning parliamentary support for naval funding

Build a parliamentary coalition before the funding dispute reaches the Treasury, explaining ship programmes to MPs and securing support from the prime minister and chancellor.

Question

How can the Royal Navy persuade the Treasury to provide funding?

Short answer

Build a parliamentary coalition before the funding dispute reaches the Treasury, explaining ship programmes to MPs and securing support from the prime minister and chancellor.

Notes

The proposed approach starts by securing Parliament's support before the Treasury determines the outcome. Support confined to the defence select committee is judged insufficient. The historical example is the Third Sea Lord briefing MPs from constituencies involved in shipbuilding, explaining what the ships would provide and encouraging them to lobby the prime minister and chancellor. A government committed to the programme could then insist on funding despite Treasury resistance. Apparent Treasury power raises the question of whether civil servants can overrule elected ministers. Alex offers the sceptical interpretation that governments may use the Treasury to explain away promises they have found too costly or difficult, much as they previously blamed the European Union. That remains his suspicion about political blame shifting.