Q&A ยท 3:36:37-3:37:48

Marine artillery sinking a cruiser at Guadalcanal

The hypothetical sinking adds one Japanese cruiser loss and a celebrated Marine unit, with little wider effect on the war.

Question

What if Marines used four 6-inch batteries to sink a Japanese cruiser at Guadalcanal?

Short answer

Japan would lose another cruiser, while the Marine unit would probably become famous and inspire a film.

Notes

The additional cruiser loss is the direct military consequence envisaged, with little wider change to the war. The unit would probably become well remembered and attract a popular film account. Any disobedience of orders could become part of that hero story. A joking extension imagines a superior officer being unfairly blamed in the retelling. These are speculative consequences of the scenario.