Q&A · 2:21:51-2:22:53

Why giant ELF submarine antennas can still be defended

ELF arrays can be placed well inland, where the depth of defended territory matters more than size alone.

Question

Are extremely low frequency submarine-communication antennas vulnerable because they are so large?

Short answer

They remain vulnerable, but remote inland siting and strong defences can make an attack a major operation; a nuclear ballistic missile is raised as the extreme alternative.

Notes

The size of an ELF installation makes it vulnerable in principle. Its location is flexible, so it can be placed in a remote interior region behind substantial defences. Reaching it could require a large conventional strike, with a nuclear-armed ballistic missile raised as the extreme alternative. A suggested American location is corrected because the facility being recalled uses very low frequency communications, not extremely low frequency. The distinction matters when comparing the installations.