Could Britain have designed a better heavy cruiser in the Admiral Hipper size range?
Short answerProbably, because continuous cruiser-design experience, operational requirements, and pressure for efficiency would favor a better use of the displacement.
NotesA British cruiser of 16,000-20,000 tons might carry at least twelve 8-inch guns. Its expected advantage comes from continuous cruiser-design experience and Treasury pressure to use money efficiently. Keeping politicians away from detailed design would also keep the requirements close to operational needs. Germany's interruption in cruiser building and competing design demands are presented as disadvantages. The United States would probably benefit from much the same continuity as Britain.