Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 2:30:48-2:33:17

Which fast battleship gave its nation the most capability?

Service duration and national need matter more than specifications alone, producing different answers for Britain, America, and Germany.

Fast BattleshipsKing George V Class Battleships (1939)North Carolina Class BattleshipsScharnhorst Class BattleshipsWorld War II
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

Which World War II fast battleship gave its nation the greatest capability for most of the war?

Short answer

There is no single answer: King George V has a strong British case, North Carolina an American one, and Scharnhorst arguably added the most relative capability to its own navy.

Notes

The criterion is useful capability delivered to a navy during the war. King George V has a strong British case, while North Carolina receives the American preference because the Iowas arrive comparatively late. A competing choice is Scharnhorst: the class supplied Germany with fast capital ships when alternatives were scarce and achieved more than Bismarck or Tirpitz. The objection is that both ships were driven off by Renown, an older battlecruiser. Their defenders reply that relative usefulness to Germany is the stated measure, even if that also exposes the weakness of the rest of its surface fleet.