Q&A · 43:00-45:08

How long could Belgrano have remained a threat?

The panel argues that even without the torpedo hit, Belgrano faced a rapidly converging British response.

Question

If General Belgrano had not been hit, how much longer could it have remained in action?

Short answer

Only hours in wartime, because British missiles and surface forces were closing on it; without the war it could have lasted longer in service.

Notes

The estimate is that General Belgrano would have lasted only a few more hours in combat because other British forces and weapons were closing on it. Exocet and other surface-to-surface missiles are mentioned alongside a surface action group. The captain and ship are initially recalled incorrectly, then corrected to John Coward in HMS Brilliant. There is also a suggestion that sparing Belgrano would have increased British interest in attacking the Argentine carrier. If the war had never happened, a further decade of service is considered plausible. These are counterfactual judgments about the ship's prospects, rather than a certain timetable for an alternative sinking.