Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 1:15:58-1:21:30

Mogami versus MEKO for Australia's light frigate

In the December 2024 comparison, Mogami is favored for Pacific operations, while Australia's MEKO experience makes either design defensible and missile capacity remains a concern.

FrigatesMEKO 200Mogami Class FrigatesRoyal Australian NavyVertical Launch Systems
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

Should the Royal Australian Navy choose the Mogami class or MEKO 200?

Short answer

Mogami is the stronger Pacific-oriented choice, although the requirement itself asks a light frigate to do too much.

Notes

Australia's experience with MEKO-derived ships makes that design a familiar option, and both candidates receive qualified support. The Egyptian MEKO example is described as having a range of 7,200 nautical miles at 16 knots and an official top speed of 28 knots. Mogami's advantages include an ongoing construction program with a Pacific partner, speed above 30 knots, combined diesel and gas-turbine propulsion, Mark 41 launchers, and minelaying equipment. Those features make Mogami the preferred choice in this December 2024 discussion. The unresolved concern is whether a light frigate can provide the missile capacity and range of roles Australia wants.