Q&A · 2:54:11-2:56:24

How would Algérie fare against Mogami?

The likely winner depends on battery configuration and, above all, which lightly protected cruiser lands the first damaging salvo.

Question

How would a fight between Algérie and a Mogami-class cruiser unfold?

Short answer

Mogami would usually be favored, but both were vulnerable enough that the first accurate heavy salvo could determine the result.

Notes

Mogami carried more weapons and had stronger magazine protection, which generally favored the Japanese cruiser. In either the fifteen-gun six-inch or ten-gun eight-inch configuration, both ships remained vulnerable enough that the first effective hit could dominate the fight. Algérie's eight-inch shells gave her a real chance if she struck first. The comparison therefore turns on configuration and the opening accurate salvo as much as nominal armament totals.